Reviews | 01 December 2018

Volkswagen Golf SV versus Renault Scenic versus Toyota Prius+

  • Cool Compact Carriers
    1 / 24 Cool Compact Carriers

    Two decades ago, the thought of buying an MPV was a depressing one for car lovers.

    Most models were bland and boxy-looking, with space and practicality being the main priorities. And in terms of performance and handling, these boxes on wheels were as about as exciting to drive as they were to look at.

    These three compact MPVs, however, not only boast snazzy styling, but pretty decent performance, too.

    The newest contender in our market is the Toyota Prius+. Replacing the popular Wish model, the Prius+ offers a versatile cabin (it’s the only seven-seater here) and an efficient petrol-electric drivetrain.

    With standard 20-inch wheels and a relatively masculine design, the Renault Scenic tries to look more like an SUV than an MPV. It will aim to sway buyers with its well-equipped and lounge-like interior.

    The oldest model in this shootout is the Volkswagen Golf SV. But thanks to a recent facelift, the Golf SV doesn’t look a day older than when it first arrived a few years ago. And although passenger space is similar to the previous model’s, there are new amenities to help it stay current.

    Which of these MPVs will prove the most tempting to potential buyers with a $120,000 budget? Continue reading and find out.


    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Engine
    2 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Engine

    Volkswagen’s turbocharged 1.4-litre 4-cylinder with 123hp and 200Nm is the most refined and responsive engine in this story.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Gearbox
    3 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Gearbox

    Golf SV’s 7-speed dual-clutch gearbox isn’t as seamless as the Scenic’s, but its gearchanges are the speediest of the three.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Engine
    4 / 24 Renault Scenic – Engine

    Renault’s 1.5-litre 4-cylinder turbo-diesel with 110hp and 260Nm has the meatiest low-end performance.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Gearbox
    5 / 24 Renault Scenic – Gearbox

    Scenic’s 7-speed dual-clutch transmission has the sportiest manual override function, as the -/+ points are in the “correct” positions.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Engine
    6 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Engine

    Toyota’s 1.8-litre inline-4 petrol-electric hybrid with 98hp and 142Nm is the least powerful, but by far most efficient drivetrain.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Gearbox
    7 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Gearbox

    Toyota’s CVT is relatively smooth, but its “rubber band” feel and lack of a manual override function discourages spirited driving.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Ride & Handling
    8 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Ride & Handling

    Golf SV is the nimblest of the group, oftentimes feeling no larger than the Golf hatchback it’s based on.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Ride & Handling
    9 / 24 Renault Scenic – Ride & Handling

    Scenic’s ride quality is surprisingly good considering its relatively large wheels. Its composed handling adds to the driver’s confidence, too.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Ride & Handling
    10 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Ride & Handling

    Prius+ has the most pliant and cosseting ride, making it ideal for families who love going on road trips.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Cockpit
    11 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Cockpit

    Most practical cockpit has the largest doorbins and offers the most supportive seats, too. Overall visibility here is the best, thanks to the low dashboard and standard blind spot monitor.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Cockpit
    12 / 24 Renault Scenic – Cockpit

    Most flexible cockpit is the only one with a sliding centre console, which can accommodate six phablets and a few power banks. Chunky steering wheel has the most positive feel, but the unintuitive cruise control layout continues to be a bugbear.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Cockpit
    13 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Cockpit

    First-time MPV owners will appreciate the low seat height, which makes ingress/egress here the easiest. Overall practicality, however, is the lowest as the storage points are woefully small.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Meters
    14 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Meters

    Analogue cluster is the most “low-tech” of the group, but is the most user-friendly because the settings are the easiest to access and tweak.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Meters
    15 / 24 Renault Scenic – Meters

    Snazziest instrument panel of the three is also the most customisable, with four layouts and five colour schemes to suit the driver’s mood.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Meters
    16 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Meters

    Centrally positioned display can be a novelty for kids, who will enjoy watching the power flow animation. The screen could be bigger, though.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Backseat
    17 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Backseat

    Roomiest backseat of the trio easily accommodates 1.8m tall occupants with headroom to spare. The centre armrest here is also more supportive than the one in the Scenic’s.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Backseat
    18 / 24 Renault Scenic – Backseat

    Shortest backrests of the group make this space more ideal for kids than adults. That said, the Scenic’s unique folding backrests make turning this space into a cargo hold the easiest.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Backseat
    19 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Backseat

    Best for accommodating three adults as it’s the sole contender with a flat floor. And as the only MPV with an extra pair of seats, the Prius+ is the most versatile, too.

    Read more
  • Volkswagen Golf SV – Boot
    20 / 24 Volkswagen Golf SV – Boot

    Golf SV’s 500-litre capacity (rear seats up) has the lowest loading point, so it’s the most ideal for heavy items. It’s also the only space with separate compartments for loose items.

    Read more
  • Renault Scenic – Boot
    21 / 24 Renault Scenic – Boot

    Scenic’s 572-litre boot (rear seats up) is the most convenient, thanks to the remote-folding seats that make it easier to expand the capacity.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+ – Boot
    22 / 24 Toyota Prius+ – Boot

    Prius+’s 232-litre boot (rearmost seats up) expands to over 500 litres when said seats are folded, but the substantial wheel arch intrusion still means this space is better suited to smaller pieces of luggage.

    Read more
  • Toyota Prius+, Renault Scenic and Volkswagen Golf SV – Keys
    23 / 24 Toyota Prius+, Renault Scenic and Volkswagen Golf SV – Keys

    Prius+ fob (left) is so light and compact you’ll forget that it’s in your pocket, Scenic’s card-type device (middle) has the most functions; buttons on the Golf SV’s key (right) are the largest and nicest to press.

    Read more
  • Last Word
    24 / 24 Last Word

    We thought that this would be a straight comparison, but as it turned out, these three compact MPVs are clearly aimed at three different types of drivers.

    The seven-seater Toyota Prius+ has to be the top choice for families with three or more kids. The Prius+ and its extra pair of seats is also the most versatile, because when not in use, said seats can be folded to expand the available boot space.

    And with its proven petrol-electric drivetrain, the Prius+ has the clear advantage when it comes to economy and running costs, too.

    For all its flexibility, the Prius+ surprisingly isn’t very practical, for its storage points are rather small. And despite Toyota’s powerful air-con, we’re pretty sure backseat passengers would appreciate some rear air-con vents.

    We love the Renault Scenic’s design and as petrolheads, definitely like the look of its 20-inch wheels, too.
    The Scenic’s meaty low-end performance is also something we enjoyed, because it’s perfectly suited to city driving conditions.

    We also love the Scenic’s cool cockpit, with its customisable instrument panel and sliding centre console. But we were less impressed with the rear bench’s short backrests and the boot’s relatively high loading point.

    The most well-rounded MPV in this story is the Volkswagen Golf SV. It may not have the versatility of the Prius+ or the stylishness of the Scenic, but the Golf SV delivers where it counts.

    This VW’s cockpit accords the driver the best all-round visibility. Its infotainment system is the most intuitive and its backseat is the roomiest in this segment.

    Performance-wise, the Golf SV is also the most appealing MPV in the story. Keen drivers with a $120k budget should definitely consider this contender.

    Suzuki Swift versus Mazda 2 and Honda Jazz

    Honda Civic takes on Skoda Octavia and Renault Megane Sedan

    Read more